Questions & Answers
   November 2008
 
 
 
This is the sixty-second (62nd) of the monthly series that Elizabeth “Libby” Pollard answered your questions regarding Parliamentary Procedures. The answers are based on Robert’s Rules of Order Newly Revised – 10th Edition (RONR).
 
Withdrawal: motion not pending
 
A motion was laid on the table. Later, during the same meeting, with no business pending, the sponsor asked permission to withdraw the motion.
Was the request in order?
Would the request have been in order after adjournment, that is, at a later meeting?
 
Opinion: The request to withdraw was not in order unless the motion was first taken from the table. The motion had been temporarily disposed of by the assembly and, in order to be withdrawn would have to be brought back to the assembly before the expiration of the time limit of the motion to lay on the table. In an organization meeting as often as quarterly, that would be before the end of the next session.
 
The above opinion is from the Parliamentary Opinions (American Institute of Parliamentarians) by Virginia Schlotzhauer, William J. Evans and John R. Stipp.
 
NOTE:
If you have a question regarding parliamentary procedures, you can send it to Libby Pollard via e-mail (ParliLibby@yahoo.com) or fax it to (614) 882-1808. Please try to limit your question to 50 words or less. Libby will try to answer your questions to the best of her ability. Thank you.
 
 

Click selected filename below to open and print; 

 

62.       Withdrawal: motion not pending - November 2008

             Questions-Answers_Nov_2008.doc

  

61.       Question of privilege: abuse - October 2008

             Questions-Answers_Oct_2008.doc

 

60.       Question of privilege: procedure - September 2008

             Questions-Answers_Sep_2008.doc

 

59.       Recess: length of recess - August 2008

            Questions-Answers_Aug_2008.doc

 

58.      Interruption of vote by motion to lay on the table - July 2008

            Questions-Answers_Jul_2008.doc

 

57.      Call for the orders of the day - June 2008

            Questions-Answers_Jun_2008.doc

 

56.      Privileged motions: why so called - May 2008

           Questions-Answers_May_2008.doc  

 

55.      Renewal of withdrawn motion - April 2008

           Questions-Answers_Apr_2008.doc  

 

54.      Committee chairman's participation - March 2008

           Questions-Answers_Mar_2008.doc 

 

53.      Election by plurality - February 2008

           Questions-Answers_Feb_2008.doc       

      

52.      Postpone indefinitely: purpose - January 2008

           Questions-Answers_Jan_2008.doc

 

51.      Rescind and expunge - December 2007

           Questions-Answers_Dec_2007.doc 

 

50.      Minutes: demand to record member's vote - November 2007

           Questions-Answers_Nov_2007.doc

 

49.      Past president/immediate past president - October 2007

           Questions-Answers_Oct_2007.doc 

 

48.      When can a division be called? - September 2007

            Questions-Answers_Sep_2007.doc

 

47.      Tie vote - August 2007

            Questions-Answers_Aug_2007.doc  

 

46.      Vacancy: appointment of replacement - July 2007

            Questions-Answers_Jul_2007.doc 

 

45.      Secretary cast ballot - June 2007

            Questions-Answers_Jun_2007.doc 

 

44.      Gender-neutral bylaws - May 2007

            Questions-Answers_May_2007.doc

 

43.      Withdrawal: consent of seconder - April 2007

            Questions-Answers_Apr_2007.doc 

 

42.      Censure - March 2007

            Questions-Answers_Mar_2007.doc 

 

41.      Removal of committee member - February 2007

            Questions-Answers_Feb_2007.doc

 

40.     When president is candidate - January 2007

           Questions-Answers_Jan_2007.doc

 

39.      Bylaw interpretation: meeting scheduled on holiday - December 2006

            Questions-Answers_Dec_2006.doc

 

38.      Parliamentarian taking initiative in advising chair - November 2006

            Questions-Answers_Nov_2006.doc

 

37.      Informal discussion without motion - October 2006

            Questions-Answers_Oct_2006.doc

 

36.     Common errors in minutes - September 2006

           Questions-Answers_Sep_2006.doc 

 

35.     Delaying time of adjournment - August 2006

           Questions-Answers_Aug_2006.doc 

 

34.     Point of information: abuse - July 2006

           Questions-Answers_Jul_2006.doc 

 

33.     Credentials list of delegates - June 2006

           Questions-Answers_Jun_2006.doc  

 

32.     Instruction of delegates - May 2006

           Questions-Answers_May_2006.doc

 

31.     Nominee for two offices - April 2006

           Questions-Answers_Apr_2006.doc   

 

30.     Disposition of ballots - March 2006

           Questions-Answers_Mar_2006.doc

 

29.     Renewal of main motion - February 2006

           Questions-Answers_Feb_2006.doc

 

28.    Counting president in committee quorum - January 2006

          Questions-Answers_Jan_2006.doc 

 

27.    Minutes of executive session - December 2005

          Questions-Answers_Dec_2005.doc 

 

26.    Selection of the parliamentarian - November 2005

          Questions-Answers_Nov_2005.doc 

 

25.    Lay on the table: prevention of abuse - October 2005

           Questions-Answers_Oct_2005.doc 

 

24.    Which candidate should be dropped? - September 2005

         Questions-Answers_Sep_2005.doc

 

23.    Abstentions: calling for - August 2005

          Questions-Answers_Aug_2005.doc 

 

22.    Take from the table - July 2005

          Questions-Answers_Jul_2005.doc

 

21.    Co-chairman - June 2005

          Questions-Answers_Jun_2005.doc

 

20.    Withdrawal: Approval of Maker - May 2005

          Questions-Answers_May_2005.doc

 

19.   Suspend the rules; protection of member's rights - April 2005

         Questions-Answers_Apr_2005.doc   

 

18.   Point of order vs call to order - March 2005

         Questions-Answers_Mar_2005.doc

 

17.   President as ex-officio member of committees - February 2005

         Questions-Answers_Feb_2005.doc

 

16.   Resignation of newly elected president - January 2005

         Questions-Answers_Jan_2005.doc

 

15.   Vice president runs for president - December 2004

         Questions-Answers_Dec_2004.doc

 

14.   Nominating chairman conducting election - November 2004

         Questions-Answers_Nov_2004.doc

 

13.   Past President - October 2004

         Questions-Answers_Oct_2004.doc

 

12.   Secretary Pro Tem - September 2004

         Questions-Answers_Sep_2004.doc

 

11.   Straw Vote - August 2004

         Questions-Answers_Aug_2004.doc

 

10.   Not in order vs. out of order - July 2004

         Questions-Answers_Jul_2004.doc

 

9.   Appeal after Parliamentary Inquiry - June 2004

      Questions-Answers_Jun_2004.doc

 

8.   Election by acclamation - May 2004

      Questions-Answers_May_2004.doc

 

7.   Request for recount - April 2004

      Questions-Answers_Apr_2004.doc

 

6.   Withdrawn motion included in minutes - March 2004  

      Questions-Answers_Mar_2004.doc

 

5.    Reconsideration of tie vote - February 2004 

       Questions-Answers_Feb_2004.doc

 

4.   Executive Session: Who remains? - January 2004

      Questions-Answers_Jan_2004.doc

 

3.   Lay on the Table vs. Postpone - December 2003

      Questions-Answers_Dec_2003.doc

 

2.   Friendly Amendment - November 2003

      Questions-Answers_Nov_2003.doc       

 

1.   Motion vs. Resolution - October 2003

      Questions-Answers_Oct_2003.doc

 

Powered by CitySlide.com